Update to original post – I went back to my method of partially cooking my chunky applesauce on the stove top, and then canning it. Perfection!
To each 5 quart saucepan of cut up apples, I added 1 cup water, 1 cup sugar, and cinnamon, nutmeg & vanillla to taste. I cooked the apples on medium heat just until the mixture started to bubble. I removed the pans from the heat and stirred the pot!! Just to incorporate the uncooked apples with the cooked pieces. I covered the pans while I finished preparing my jars and lids.
I processed these in my pressure canner for 10 minutes at 5 pounds pressure. I process almost everything in my pressure cooker, I use less water, and it takes less time.
The dark jar is some of the apple butter that was made from the peels and cores.

If someone asked me what apple would be best for a homesteader just starting out, I would have to say, Yellow Transparent. I know it won’t win any prizes for keeping until May, or holding up firmly in pie. But, it is disease resistant, sets fruit at a young age, bears every year, is the first apple to ripen, and is very tart which makes it a good cooking and eating apple. All those attributes make it a very good selection for someone interested in self-reliance.
However, it is often discarded as a mushy, old time apple. Sure, if you wait until it is dead ripe to pick it – but I would think any fruit or vegetable past its prime would be tasteless too. The key is harvesting when the apples are still light green, just beginning to get a yellow tinge.

I harvested all the apples on the Yellow Transparent in our yard/orchard this week. Depending on your location, Yellow Transparent may ripen in July for you, for us it is early August. This apple is very fragrant and brings the deer in – and they relish apples after carrots and beans, so I make sure I remove the temptation.
I usually start out with grand ideas when I start to preserve something – most of the time it works out, and sometimes not. This time is in between, and here is how the experiment went.
And before you start shaking your head or getting worried about people who mix canning and experimentation. Just know this, jams and jellies are a gateway drug – once you get hooked there is no turning back ;)

First I was going to make my moms chunky applesauce, because I really can’t stand the pablum-like, food mill style applesauce. I do make some with the food mill if we have small apples that are a pain to peel, but most of that ends up in applesauce cake or something of that nature.
A dream meal for me is mashed potatoes, gravy, pork roast and chunky applesauce! So with pork roast on my mind I began peeling these nice large apples.

Next they went into their salt water bath to prevent them from darkening while I worked my way through the first box.
Mild salt solution: 1½ teaspoon salt per quart of cold water.

Then I cored and quartered the apples, putting them back in the salt water bath as I worked. At this point my mind began wandering, and I kept thinking about a canned apple pie filling recipe I had somewhere… . In the recipe, the apples are sliced and mixed with a huge amount of sugar and left overnight to release their juice. I had tried this before, and we could not stomach the sweetness, even though the recipe calls for the addition of lemon juice. To me it seemed a waste to take a tart apple and add too much sugar, and then add lemon juice to try to recreate what was there in the first place. So the ‘ol brain started creaking, and lurched into gear – maybe I could use less sugar, but still let the apples sit overnight and then can the results. I still wanted chunky applesauce, but I was trying to get out of cooking it and then canning it. I just wanted to can it in the jars, since these are not the firmest of apples I was hoping this would work.
Let me say here, experimenting with canning fruits is safe. Fruits are high acid, and will just spoil or ferment, and it will be apparent, so there isn’t the danger factor of vegetables, tomatoes, and meat products. Do not experiment with recipes for those types of foodstuffs. Please.

My next step was to cut the apples in chunks, and add my other ingredients.
In a large mixing bowl of diced apples: (I used a 3½ quart)
2 cups sugar
1 Tablespoon cinnamon
1 teaspoon nutmeg
2 T vanilla
Stir all ingredients together, cover and let sit overnight to allow the apples to release their juice.

Here is where things started to go awry. The next morning, (ominous music in background) pack sterilized jars with apples. Heat the apple juice and pour over fruit.
When I can I always have a smaller jar on hand, because I never just end up with an exact amount. So for this batch, I had 5 quarts of diced apples and 1 pint. Because I was going to can these in my pressure canner, I left about a 2″ headspace to allow for expansion. I called a canning partner in crime, and we discussed the pros and cons of my messing with the recipe and when I got off the phone and looked at those jars, I decided to unpack the pint and put a just a little more in each quart. Mistake – I knew it might be, but sometimes, well all the time, I have to learn the hard way. Once that canner is closed, there is no turning back, the next time I would see my “apple whatever” would be when the pressure was down, and I could experience the moment of truth.

A watch gauge never drops fast enough.

Mea Culpa! See the applesauce blurping down the side of the jar? That means I did overfill the jars, and when the cool contents expanded during the canning/cooking process, the pressure forced the contents out of the jar.
Why am I telling you all this? Because I want you to know that it is OK to experiment a little after you have a few seasons of canning under your belt. And that even veteran canners make mistakes, and are still alive to laugh about it.
Next box, I am going back to my moms method and I will cook it first and then can it, and when I do that I will let you know how it turns out. Meanwhile, I will mark these 5 jars with a notation to use first, since I will need to watch their seals because of the liquid being forced from the jars.
Since I am supposed to post at another blog today, I have wrote about what I did to glean almost every last drop of usefulness from these homegrown apples there.








At a restaurant in Sisters, OR called “The Gallery” I had the most delicious chunky applesauce I’ve ever sunk a tooth into. I’ve been trying to recreate it ever since. Although Hubby loves trying my failures, I still haven’t come close. It must be in the varieties of apple I’m using.
Peggy, I know what you mean, the failures around here disappear pretty fast too!
Tart apples make the best sauce, but unless you go to a farmers market it is hard to find a good cooking apple. But from the store, Braeburn and Granny Smith aren’t too bad.
In the piedmont of NC, “Grimes Golden” is the best apple for sauce according to Mom. (At least it was the best of the varieties we grew.)
I just have to put in a plug for “Black Twig” also. It seems to be fairly disease free, good keeper, and you can fry (saute, really) it in the skillet with a little butter and NO sugar and still have a sweet dish.
Bonnie, Grimes Golden is a great keeper too. We have one ancient tree and it doesn’t bear consistently anymore. But they sure are good. I have never had the opportunity to try a Black Twig, but I love the name!
We love sauteed apples too – that’s kind of a staple here for lunch during winter. Delicious! I would have to say Northern Spy is my favorite.
Oh, and one more thing — when you saute “Black Twig” or “Limber Twig” leave the peel on. Delicious!
Bonnie, we leave the peels on too – pretty tasty
Those are simply beautiful, I love newly canned jars all lined up in my pantry! I love Gravenstein apples, although they only bear well every other year, their ‘on’ year is the best ever for applesauce!!! Kim
Kim, our Gravenstein’s bear every year, but our Northern Spies bear every other year. Each one is my favorite when I am eating them. It’s hard to beat Gravensteins for cider too!
I always make chunky applesauce, cooking it first and I use a water bath to can. I only add cinnamon and a hint of water to keep it from burning. I also love to make applesauce fresh for meals like roast pork, potatoes and gravy. That’s one of my favorites, too! We’re out of pork roasts now, but come November when we slaughter the pigs we’ll get more. mmmmmmm
Abbie, I made my chunky sauce today and I was a good girl, and quickly cooked it and then canned with the water bath canner. Maybe my experimentation is done for the year – and I can get on to business.
I usually make the fresh sauce for breakfast too, it is so fast, and I leave the peels in. Yummy.
This is an off year for most of our apples, including the Transparent; so we will have to get by on our McIntosh. But will review this post when it is time to get crackin’!
Risa B, our Tranparent crop was low this year – I only picked 100#, usually there is so many more, but our spring was so wet, I am surprised there was much pollination at all. I have seen a total of 6 pears on as many trees – but our prunes are covered.
At least we will still have plenty of fruit, and we are happy to get that.
Chunky applesauce…it’s the ONLY way to go. No baby food for us.
We also cook first, can second. It seems to work out best that way…and it’s quicker than letting it sit overnight.
BTW…we have yellow transparent too. We inherited it when we purchased this house. We always thought it was the MOST horrible apple with such a mealy texture and almost no sweetness or even flavor. That is until we figured out it ripens at the first of June for us here and not in the late summer as we expected. Now that we know this…we pick and can it early. Usually as an addition to some berries or other early fruits since my tree isn’t very large. However…it is very disease resistant (and even pest resistant) for us and we have really not ever had to mess with it like some of the other trees. Good choice over all—just be prepared, as you said, to harvest early for this variety.
Monica
This is funny, because I read Simple Green Frugal Co-op too, and saw the same pics on there that are on here of the jars of apples and thought, ok, someone is swiping pics. Turns out, you are one and the same! Small world eh? Those apples look yummy.