I cook from scratch for many reasons. It saves money, I can cook without additives, I can be creative, and I’m in control of my food. Does it take longer? Yeah, I guess, if you count the time it took me to grow the beef in the Beef Pot Pie recipe I’m going to give you. About 2 years and 9 months. You could use chicken, it only takes several months, and in that case some of the vegetables I used took longer than that. I’m not trying to be sarcastic, just honest in how involved in my food I am.
I grew up cooking from a well stocked pantry, and I stock my pantry well now. I have everything I need on hand to cook many different types of meals, and I know how and when to make substitutions. This post will be boring for scratch cooks, but I want to show how easy it is when you have an array of ingredients in your pantry. I’m using the term pantry loosely here, too, my pantry consists of home canned foods, frozen foods, root cellar, garden, and dry goods. During the preserving season, I don’t make a lot of convenience foods ahead of time. If I make so many jars of marinara sauce, then I’m locked into that flavor for a set amount of jars, so I put up tomato puree instead, and I can use it in any recipe by adding seasoning at the time of cooking. Ditto for the meat, I have ground pork instead of sausage in my freezer; spices can become bitter over time, and I can thaw out small amounts and add seasonings to fit my recipe.
And, that recipe thing, sometimes you need a recipe, and sometimes the recipe serves as a guideline, allowing you to add your own special touch and homegrown ingredients to your liking. This recipe for Pot Pie is one I use frequently to stretch our homegrown meats. I follow the crust recipe, but the pot pie filling is a “whatever is on-hand” vegetable and meat mixture. If you’re not into meat, it can be all vegetables.
Actual prep and cooking time is approximately 1 hour. Preparing the fresh vegetables and crust are done simultaneously and take about 1/2 hour, and the actual baking of the pie takes 1/2 hour. I used to work off the farm, so many of my recipes are from that time. I’m still working, just here, but I still need to break up my food prep time. A real time saver is to have the vegetables ready to cook beforehand. The prep work could be done the night before, or sometime during the day. Another note on this is: I don’t try to rush my food. To be nourishing, food needs as much attention as other aspects of our lives.

From the garden: rutabaga, carrots, and celeriac.
From the basement: storage onion and garlic.
I won’t use every bit of these vegetables, I am aiming to fill my #8 cast iron skillet, which will in turn fill my 9 x 13 baking dish. The more you cook, the easier it is to judge these amounts.
Here are my approximate quantities for this 6 serving pot pie filling:
1 medium onion
3 cloves garlic
1 cup of chopped celery stems and leaves
3 or 4 carrots
1 medium rutabaga or 1/2 large
1 celery root
1 cup frozen peas
1 cup chopped leftover meat
1 or 2 cups broth or leftover gravy
1 – 2 T arrowroot powder for thickening (easier to digest than cornstarch or flour)

Celeriac is starting to become more of a staple here. My celery didn’t survive our 11°F cold spell, but the celeriac tops, while still a little rough, have enough good stalks and leaves to season my rustic mire poix that I’m going to make for my pot pie filling. Since the celeriac lends a mild celery flavor to the mix, I will only use half the tops, reserving the rest for flavor for soups, etc.
My husband is allergic to potatoes so I no longer can add potatoes to this. But, they would be a more traditional ingredient. I also added frozen peas harvested from our garden. More on that later.

First, you build a fire… no, never mind that.
Brown onion, garlic and celeriac tops in butter or oil until onions began to caramelize. While these are cooking, prepare your root vegetables. Try to cut uniform pieces so they cook at the same rate.

A note on rutabaga’s, I prefer to grow rutabagas over turnips, since the skin is thick enough to withstand a little root maggot damage. To avoid root maggots, plan for these to mature in the fall when the temeratures are cooler. Cool weather is the brassica family’s friend.
Peel and pare away any insect damage. This was one was rather large, so I only used half.

Add vegetables to onion/celery mixture. I used leftover roast beef in this pie, so marjoram is the herb I added, with a few stems for a little fiber. ;)

Add chopped meat, gravy or broth, cover and cook over medium heat until vegetables are fork tender. I used broth and gravy in this, so I thickened the mixture with arrowroot powder.
While the vegetables are cooking, you can make the pot pie crust. I follow the recipe on this part. Well, kind of…
POT PIE CRUST
The butter will make the crust flaky, and the eggs give it some substance so it doesn’t get soggy.
1 1/2 c flour
1 t salt
5 T chilled butter
2 large eggs
2 – 3 T cold water
Combine flour and salt, mix in butter until mixture resembles coarse meal with some pea sized balls. Add eggs, mix, add water and mix until the dough comes away from the side of the bowl (it will be moist). Turn out onto floured board and roll to desired shape(s).

I eyeball the salt, this is roughly 1 teaspoon. My butter is salted so if I’m a little shy on salt, it won’t make much difference in the outcome.

Pretty close, if I hadn’t slopped it all over.

Crust with eggs mixed in.

Just starting to come away from the bowl cleanly.

I bake my pot pies, and actually a lot of my fruit pies in a 9 x 13 pan. I only use a crust on top, which saves me money (less ingredients), and instead of small individual dishes to wash, I only have one.
Shape your dough into a rough rectangle before rolling out.

I freeze some things like sweet peas and wild mushrooms in 1/2 pint jars. This makes them go a little further since they can be a little hard to come by sometimes. I love to eat peas, but I really don’t like to shell them.
Turn the cooked vegetables into your baking dish. I am adding these peas last since they are already blanched.

Use your baking dish as a rough guide to see if your crust is rolled out to enough. Remember: close counts here, this is a rustic, farm kitchen dish.

Roll up dough and place on the long side and cover filling.

I just roll the crust a little on the edges. Just try to seal the vegetables in, so your crust acts as a lid to finish the cooking process.
Bake 25 -30 minutes in a 400°F degree oven, until crust is lightly browned and the filling is bubbly. 
Dinner is served









Absolutely lovely. I like how you only put the crust on the top. Not only is it frugal, but having crust on the bottom as well as the top is just too much food at a time (and rarely gets eaten). Sorry to hear that your hubby can’t eat potatoes. You grow such lovely potatoes, too. At least he can enjoy the rest of your garden bounty in such great ways like this pot pie!
I keep a deep pantry but this year because of the move we didn’t store as many root veg as I would have liked to. Right now I’m out of carrots and it’s 18 below and I want to make your recipe with the leftover lamb and eat it for breakfast!!!! It looks fabulous.
I’ll wing it, I’m a DMS cook (don’t measure sh…..) and this will be just the ticket for dinner. Thanks!
Oh that looks delicious! I will definitely be trying it soon!
Thank gods, a sensible pot pie recipe! I keep coming across ones where you start with a hunk of raw meat, and then add stuff like heavy cream and half a pound of butter to the sauce. Which I’m sure would be delightful, but defeats the purpose of the pot pie, which is to take the leftover roast or bird and gravy and stretch it creatively into another tasty meal (or two).
Looks delicious, I’ll have to give this recipe a shot when I get some local beef. I am also a from-scratch cook. Last night we made local turkey & veggie stew with dumplings. All the ingredients I either grew myself, or I bought from small local farmers, and all of them were in my pantry (including the wheat from a local farmer that I ground for the dumplings).
Once you start eating this way, pre-packaged convenience food tastes weird. There’s no going back! Even restaurant food tastes weird most of the time.
Thanks for the recipe! We got a 1/4 cow from our cousins this year, and I’m always looking for beef recipes to use that meat in the freezer.
Wow! That looks great!
[...] a not so related note, I want to make this dish tonite. Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Worst of CES: Cell-MateLions and tigers and [...]
yum! pot pies are a favorite around here and i usually throw whatever i have leftover into them…i keep a quart jar in the freezer that i throw leftover veggies in. when it gets full, it’s pot pie time!
your hubby is allergic to potatoes?!! that’s just not right. i don’t know what we’d do w/o potatoes.
i understand the frugality of crust on the top only, but i think i’d rather have crust on the bottom….i LOVE the soggy pie crust more than the crispy top crust!!! i am just a freak, i guess.
now that these lovely photos have reminded me it’s lunchtime, i suppose i’ll go make us some sandwiches while drooling over these pictures.
Ooooh, looks delish! I’m making chicken noodle soup from scratch today. (Hubby’s Grandma’s “Chicken Noodle Soup” that is really more Amish style Chicken & dumplings.) Yeah for home-cooked (and grown, in your case) comfort food!
Mmm, what a fabulous recipe. I can’t wait to try it!
I love the art and science of from-scratch cooking. My peers, of course, think I’m insane for baking my own bread, casseroles, and desserts… because I’m 21, they think I should be out whooping it up and eating ramen instead of devouring amazing, homemade concoctions like this pot pie. Instead, I love to read about and practice frugality and homesteading.
Thanks for sharing your recipe and technique!
Paula, I like it when I can cheat and call it frugal, I do like the crust the best, but this is so much faster.
Arrgh, the potato thing, at least after 51 years he is getting somewhere with his troubles. Wheat is a sort of no-no too, so 1 crust works good for that too. Anything he wants/likes to eat, he shouldn’t, so I just cook food he hates. Easy
At least I won’t have to grow so many potatoes this year.
AnnaMarie, I actually had some leftover pot pie for breakfast! It was good.
Hope it warms up for you soon!
Jennifer, thanks.
Safira, I know what you mean, I don’t think I have ever made a pot pie that wasn’t utilizing some leftover meat. A girlfriend of mine makes it standard practice to NOT eat leftovers. I couldn’t imagine.
Susy, that sounds good. I know what you mean, about restaurant food. We rarely go out anymore, and when we do we are disappointed. It is expensive, and our food tastes so good.
Farmersdaughter, Warren, Annette, Thanks!
Tansy, I like fruit pie crust the best! Bottom and top, pot pie not so much, unless it is my chicken curry one, then I like the soggy crust.
I could live on meat and potatoes, so we just figure more for us. He likes them too, but it isn’t worth it, other solanums aren’t quite as bad.
Kati, that sound delicious! Something about comfort food in the winter.
psuklinkie, thanks and I’m glad you’re not eating ramen. Your friends don’t know what they’re missing! Yeah for scratch cooking and homesteading pursuits!
Yummy, wonderful post. I am really taking a liking to cooking from scratch. Good points you made about flavoring foods after they have been stored. I think we’ll do that with the next pig we put up.
I fixed this Friday evening, after work, and it was AMAZING! There were no left overs and many requests to fix it again. I used rutabagas just to try something new and my kids never questioned that these were not potatoes! =) I think I need to add some of these to the garden list!
My only challenge was on which seasonings to use. I do well with a recipe; however, leaving the parameters of that same recipe leave me challenged.
Any suggestions on seasonings to use with stew meat (beef)?
Thank you again for posting it.
Oh, just what I was wanting…I make some things from scratch, but do most of it by trial and error. This was just what I needed for a great basic pot pie, though I have the shepherd’s pie thing down pretty well if using the ‘taters
LOVE this, Nita!
I have written down all of the ingredients, the recipe and I’m heading out to gather up everything I need. I am making this pot pie today and I can’t wait. It looks yummy!